Although much delayed, I do wish to give my opinion on some plays I've seen in recent months. The first thing I want to talk about is performances of two operas by Bellini in concert that took place in April and May. The first was I Puritani, with the presence of Juan Diego Flórez, and the second was Standard , with Violeta Urmana in the title role. The results, for me, were irregular.
De I Puritani I have to say I got bored as an oyster, for two reasons. First because this opera is not my cup of tea. The argument is bullshit, even is flawed in its execution time, and I must say also that the interpretation that we all gave at the Royal was not particularly good. The star was Juan Diego Flórez, who was just right. It seems that the tenor had a viral infection, and it showed. In voice because when I had to climb, especially in for him easily treble the score, the throw with a wince, and one of them pierced us all cry because it was close. In addition he was preoccupied, perhaps worried, and although it is always a miracle to hear, one would expect something more from him. Finally, although Many here will kill me for what I mean, I know that is a role that has given him great success, for example in his debut in Las Palmas de Gran Canaria I could hear in his day, but I still think you need a certain courage and Heroism is not a role that edge. We need something to Peruvian Bellini, and especially for the Bellini, and I could see, despite the braveos, which certainly deserved his first appearance alone was incorporated without applause. Well, the public generally requires Real hot, and could be just that. I am convinced florez , and hopefully next time I see Juan Diego let me ecstatic, as always.
Perhaps perhaps, is a bit boring for a career that is still spectacular but if we see the evolution is no more correct, always turning over a number of roles that in the last days, there seem to evolve too. Many tell me that Kraus did not reach the score of roles throughout his life, but you have to hear one of his great roles in the 60, 70, 80 and 90 and understand what I mean, Kraus had something to say or contribute. Juan Diego Flórez as well, but perhaps needs more fresh air. His mentor, Ernesto Palacio, make sure you know. In the rest of the cast ... Irregular. Roberto Ragliavini as Gualtiero , sometimes seemed be confused and even opera voice, trying to end a left trumpet a little sharper than surprised the audience. But he was, in general, correct. Gabriella Colecchia as Enrichetta di Francia, was perfectly forgettable, annoying vibrato, too much volume that was useless, a total lack of nuance, singing line downright ugly ... A real ordeal, thankfully does not involve too much. As for the now well known Eglise Gutiérrez as Elvira ... I think one of the sopranos loosest I've seen in my life. Very Justito volume, treble, short, short, because it can not issue them and pulling forces up to the ankles ...
Cursi to despair, I do not think a singer but 2nd row 7 th ... because from the 8 th row is not listening. And if that voice as in the dramatic even worse. Cold, inconsistent ... A solemn fiasco. As I said a good friend of mine, the cleaning lady of Royal was the day after the passage of the Eglise double work for the stage by collecting all the eighth notes and sixteenth notes that the soprano was left to take, because it bounced in the throat . I will not give him another chance, I do not care about this singer. I do not think it was that night thing , I think your flaws are deeper. For the first time in my life I left the theater before they finished the applause. The Choir, only right, the orchestra better than when directed by the young owner of the same, but with some problems that sometimes are endemic but a good baton know them go away: excess volume in the winds, especially in brass. Miguel Ortega, the head of the baton that night, was good, but neither got the score Belliniano everything ... Or maybe it's no more to take.
Standard was something else. Because it is a piece of opera. Musically, it is good to the overture. Vibrant, round, inspired. Has musical moments that lead to emotional climax, the libretto is characteristic of the neoclassical period in which it develops, a Medea passed through the sieve of good taste. The characters are drawn with spirit, the dramatic beat is awesome ... An opera that can make you enjoy herself, who sing sing ... To a certain extent. Has a problem, as La Traviata or Salome, is that if the failure lead role, as can others be exceptional singers who function not walk. An example disk. The recording made in the 80 Joan Sutherland as Norma , Luciano Pavarotti as Pollione , neither more nor less than Montserrat Caballe as Adalgisa and Samuel Ramey in the role of Oroveso. Pavarotti is impressive, Caballé, despite the age and stay fighting a mezzo role (you do not explain why it used the original version which is also soprano Adalgisa) is glorious, and his duet with tenor sparks fly, possibly the best recorded version of that part of the opera. Ramey gives to spare, is a luxury for Oroveso ... But the Standard Sutherland fails. She has been one of the largest and most definitive standard of history, no doubt, arguably the best understood aspect of the character neoclassical, compared with Callas it takes too much into a more romantic and Caballé always faced riots Standard without a strong focus on the music and introspective character study. But in this record fails, and is especially noticeable in the duets with Caballe, where Catalan makes it a favor, because these two women, Olympic song, is too much respect to each other. I'm already gone through the hills of Ubeda. For that, the recording fails and ends up being boring, because despite some side are better than perfect, the head fails. It is one of the major problems Standard. Luckily, the night of the representation in the Royal this did not happen. Waited with curiosity absolute Violeta Urmana in the paper.
Nobody believed in principle suitable for the role. But Urmana is one of the most serious and intelligent singers of the moment, and not face any role not only not sure of it, but without having studied it over and over again. I have already said on this blog that the problem I have with Urmana is his vocal and stage cold. Well the funny thing is that it Standard in their favor. Not the ideal Standard , perhaps. Neither reference ... It is not that when you face a role. But I have not so clear that the paper is inappropriate for her. Announced the public address Urmana theater that was not quite good health. Well should have taken a couple of aspirin before going on stage, because except for some occasional difficulties in a couple of highs, it is certain that it was good, went out of step with remarkable, and we are thrilled. Was able to bring the score to their potential, not got out of it or wanted to decorate it (as did Caballé), was sincere, and everything went well. I liked it, I was excited, and repeat without hesitation. A solvent soprano who made a Standard solvent. And according to the neoclassicism of the piece, her voice was cold on his part, as perhaps happened with Sutherland. It was the perfect tone. For me, the more time that Violeta Urmana I enjoyed ... Although someone should tell some of the suits, because he took out one that looked just stolen Count Dracula in a postmodern version. Carlo Colombo, as Oroveso , I was disappointed, and that was my bet. Did not become the night, was extremely accurate and very boring. Francesco Hong, in the role of Pollione , I can only adjectives with very little recurring word in the world of musical chronicle: a real pain in the ass . Bored, looking foolish when he had to be heroic, an idiot when it should be in love, and who knows what all else. Very fluid in his sharp, but lost everything else. A singer with no middle is none, and Hong does not have middle. Real bet, but failed, this man bore up to the sheep. The great revelation and a sensation of the evening was Sonia Ganassi, mezzo, who nailed the role of Adalgisa . Hong fighting in his first speech, and the glory grating parts with Violeta Urmana. That sounds like a mezzo mezzo, as before. The character well learned and internalized, it dominated with greatness. A loud voice to take into account in the future: either in the acute area, right in the grave, great in everything else. Real hope gives you more opportunities, because is a great singer, and deserves to become a star at best. Phrasing, vocalism, timbre, beauty ... It has everything.
The orchestra sounded tremendously well, with Massimo Zanetti to the head, with none of the problems that sometimes drags and sounding like López Cobos never got to hear (yet what fools say solemnly that he will be sorely less when you go ... bunch of morons, have had a season in which the orchestra sounded just fine when he was not directing it, and are talking nonsense). The choir also behaved and that he was among its members Mrs. Zapatero ... Someday I should explain that makes this lady speaking on representations that do not play, here and out of here, while other singers who make their living from it are left at home ... Maybe it does not happen later this month (had to say, the discreet following making your life what it actually does take work to those who truly need and deserve ... and if not who is singing noses would see where we sing).
0 comments:
Post a Comment